Israel, Palestine and My SodaStream

Last week our congregation voted to support a resolution calling for may 2015 007support of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions or BDS movement, which seeks to use economic and political pressure to force Israel to withdraw from the West Bank.  The United Church of Christ will vote on a resolution to support this same resolution when our General Synod meets in June.

In our conversation here on May 3, members shared articulate and passionate comments. Their personal experience in the Middle East. Their feelings about the situation of the Palestinians. The use or misuse of the word “apartheid” to talk about the situation of the Palestinians in occupied territory. The need to remember the suffering inflicted on Israel. The nature of complexity.  The feeling that this resolution would not do anything to support a lasting peace. Questions about the political motivations of the BDS movement. That more dialogue is needed before a vote. The need not to isolate others in our interfaith dialogue.

A good conversation and what felt like the beginning of a longer one that is needed. A ballot was taken and our congregation voted 84 in favor of supporting the resolution, 4 against, and 10 abstentions.

may 2015 008A couple of years ago, I bought a SodaStream. Sparkling water is my favorite drink of choice and after years of hauling plastic liter container after container home from the store and then tossing them into my recycling bin, I was intrigued by the opportunity to make my own sparkling water.  No more mass accumulation of plastic bottles.  Just a Co2 cartridge I took back periodically to have refilled at the local drug store.  I loved my endless supply of sparkling water and felt quite virtuous and very “Seattle” because of my environmentally supportive purchase.

What I didn’t know, until the discussions on this resolution, is that SodaStream operates a factory in the West Bank settlement of Ma’ale Adumim. My virtuous purchase now not so virtuous. SodaStream, unbeknownst to this naive consumer, has in fact been the subject of a boycott by the BDS movement for years.

My quick internet search showed that supporters of SodaStream note that 500 of the 1300 plant employees are Palestinians and paid competitive wages for Palestine.

Others counter that SodaStream benefits, along with the 300 other may 2015 009companies operating in settlements in the West Bank, from depressed wages made possible, in part, by Israeli occupation.

In any case, SodaStream plans to close its plant and move it to Lehavim in the southern Negev this fall.

Is the specific controversy about SodaStream over? Or for others, like me, only beginning?  And what about my SodaStream that my congregation has just voted to boycott?

Liberal Christians are criticized, fairly, for not talking about sin often enough.  Our congregations bear the scars of those who for one reason or another have had a run in with churches calling them “sinful” or in need of redemption because of who they are or what they “believe”.  In our liberal church welcome of “whoever we are, wherever we are on life’s journey”, sin often gets downplayed.

may 2015 010But maybe its times like this that we need to bring back that old fashioned word again.  Right here, looking at the SodaStream on my kitchen counter is where sin makes sense to me again.  Not in the sense of “miserable wretch am I”, – but “unclean man am I” caught in a web of broken relationships. Immersed in a divided and complex world of competing notions of the “good” that are often up to no good.

No, there is no getting “off the grid” when it comes to opting out of injustice.   I am caught in the web of it.  And now, wondering what to do about it.

This is not an “abstract” or “theoretical” issue for me. The places we talked about on Sunday are places I have traveled. I have been on two study trips to Israel/Palestine. I’ve walked through refuge camps outside Bethlehem and celebrated Shabbat in Galilee. I’ve talked with Israeli settlers and Palestinians about the terrors both have witnessed. I have listened to Jewish and Arab families talk about the death of their children. I have heard story after story of suffering and seen amazing glimpses of resilience and hope. I have seen the ongoing divides of the history of hurt that cripples this land and throws it back on cycle of violence after cycle of violence.

My SodaStream on my kitchen counter, now brings it all back to me. What do I do? Post a picture of the refuge camp I visited in Beit Sahour next to my SodaStream? Get rid of the SodaStream and let someone else pick up the responsibility for owning it?  Stop refilling the little Co2 cartridges?  Keep supporting an industry on occupied territory that my church has supported boycotting?

Maybe it doesn’t matter.  Maybe the harm has been done. I already bought my SodaStream.  But maybe I can’t get off the hook so easy. Maybe this is right where I need to be. Maybe sitting here today in the not-knowing.

And if I can’t get out of the web of injustice, but how might I get further into it so I might find my way through?

The worst thing about the “resolutions” we pass is when we have our brief may 2015 011conversations, feel vindicated or defeated, and then move on.  The possibility of these “resolutions” is when they become an opening for deeper dialogue and engagement.

Maybe the occasion to prompt another study trip to Israel and Palestine? Maybe an occasion to gather our SodaStreams on the communion table, and listen to their stories?

Maybe, to listen to our own. Our hurt and displacement. Our longing to be instruments of hope and peace. Often not knowing how. But wanting to make a difference. To bring about change. To bring some water to the desert.

Maybe talking about our SodaStreams, a good place to start.

10 thoughts on “Israel, Palestine and My SodaStream

  1. What your dilemma with your SodaStream brings up for me is exactly the same problem that afflicts us when we shop at Safeway for something only they have. All the time we’re there, we feel vaguely uncomfortable because we know they hire women to run their flower store at less than full time so they don’t have to offer them benefits. It’s the same sense of unease we get if we find ourselves buying something at Walmart, because it’s the only place that carries a favorite item. We know that they don’t pay most of their employees a living wage and withhold benefits that could help the families of their employees. But we can look around and see that there are LOTS of people shopping at Safeway and Walmart and justify ourselves by telling ourselves that one more little person can’t possibly make that much difference. It’s darned hard to avoid sin in this world!

    Like

    • Thanks Susan! And for a reminder of the way it is with us and the world – the messy steps we make trying to find our way in hope and compassion in the world!

      Like

  2. Great post, Peter. I have really started to embrace this in my world. As hard as it is sometimes, I no longer shop at places with bad business practices, or that support political agendas I disagree with. What I have found is that it often steers me back to community in the process, and community is to me what needs developing to better understand the world we now live in. It does this, because we return to the mom and pop places that are a bit more expensive, generally, and perhaps not so convenient always, but it engages us locally on a different level. When we talk about things, hopefully over time they result in movement. It’s easy to buy something online or just pick up one item from a conglomerate that says it is making our lives cheaper or taking care of all of our needs. It’s the way we live today…how our culture has developed. However, as consumers in this culture that is all about consuming, sometimes the only way we can make a difference is not to shop somewhere. If enough people do that, then over time maybe things really can begin to change. In a world filled these days with so much injustice, cruelty, and down right crazy, sometimes that actually feels like the beginning of a solution to me.

    Like

  3. Thanks for reminding us so well that this is a complex issue, and that this is just a beginning for us. According to the resolution, “the hope is that individuals, churches, and church entities” … “will examine their own consciences.” My “Sodastream moment” came when I saw a clever video on Facebook about a favorite of mine, Ben and Jerry’s ice cream. Gulp. Seriously, we do want and need to continue the dialogue, to listen thoughtfully to one another. The Palestine Action Group will have a meeting on June 7 to give people further opportunities to get involved in a way that works for them. Thanks again, Peter. P.S. I do want to visit Israel and Palestine.

    Like

  4. Thanks for writing about this. At this time I could not support this resolution but this has to be talked about because of the human suffering. I am not a member but I do consider you my brother and Catherine Foote my sister. I know I don’t get a vote but I am again happy that your Church is willing to draw attention to the pain experienced by so many. I think your efforts make a difference. The Church has got to honestly talk about this. If left to the political leaders we will get political decisions and people will continue being hurt. Maybe other Churches will find the courage to take a stand when we see what you have done. Corky Hebrew 4.16

    Like

    • Thanks Corky for writing – and yes, a good place for the church at its best to be a forum to listen to one another in compassion, and care, and listening for the Spirit’s call to response/action.

      Peter

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s